Carnie Wilson’s Daughter, Lola Bonfiglio, Impresses Judges With Kacey Musgraves’ ‘Rainbow’ on ‘American Idol 2025. American Idol’ once again showcases musical talent running in the family as another star’s child takes the stage.
This time, 19-year-old Lola Bonfiglio—daughter of Wilson Phillips’ Carnie Wilson and granddaughter of The Beach Boys’ Brian Wilson—stepped up for her audition on Sunday night. Lola walked into the audition room with her dad, Rob Bonfiglio, who had his guitar in hand.
Noticing the musical connection, Carrie Underwood commented on her family’s background in music. When asked what song she would be performing, Lola brought in her mom, Carnie Wilson, and her aunt, Wendy Wilson, making it a true family moment.
Wilson Phillips Reunion Stuns Judges
At that moment, ‘American Idol’ winner Carrie Underwood realized she was standing before two members of Wilson Phillips. Surprised, she admitted, “I don’t know how to proceed now.” However, Lola’s father, Rob Bonfiglio, took the lead, strumming the opening chords of Wilson Phillips’ iconic hit “Hold On.”
As the music played, Lola Bonfiglio, Carnie Wilson, and Wendy Wilson delivered a stunning harmony, bringing their classic song to life on the ‘American Idol’ stage.
Table of Contents
Carrie Underwood on Family Harmonies
Carrie Underwood remarked on the family’s natural harmony, saying, “You can tell that it’s a thing with families—that everybody is genetically designed to sound good together.”
Lola described it as “a blood blend.”
Curious to hear her individual talent, Carrie Underwood asked Lola to perform solo, giving the judges a chance to get to know her voice better.
“I have my tissues stuffed in my bra,” Carnie joked, wiping away a few tears as she, Rob, and Wendy stepped aside. With her family watching, Lola Bonfiglio, a college student, took center stage to perform “Rainbow” by Kacey Musgraves for judges Carrie Underwood, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan.
“This audition is going to push me,” Lola shared. “I’m used to singing with my parents and family, but I’m excited to grow from this experience and challenge myself.”
Judge Feedback: Encouragement and Advice
You have everything you need, Lionel Richie told Lola. “One piece of advice—when you’re singing lead, let the story unfold. It felt like you were rushing to the end and cutting it off, maybe due to nerves. Just hold those moments longer. Your voice is there—let us feel the story.”
Your tone, purity, and vocal quality are beautiful, and that song was a perfect choice for you, Luke Bryan told Lola. “But this competition will push you to belt, let loose, and fill the room with your voice. Use your dynamics more. You’ve got a really beautiful voice.”
Carrie Underwood then shared her thoughts, saying, “You have an honesty in your voice and a strong presence. I want to see you fully own your talent and everything you have to offer—because you have a lot to offer. That excites me, and I’d love to witness your journey.”
Lola responded confidently, “If I’m on this show, I will push myself. That’s why I want to be on American Idol—I want to grow. Carrie Underwood encouraged her, saying, “You have to find your artistry, find your lane, and own it.
Lola Bonfiglio Earns a Golden Ticket to Hollywood
“I take all this to heart,” Lola added. Moments later, the judges handed her a Golden Ticket to Hollywood.
“I am so speechless,” Lola said, “but I’m so excited for this journey. No matter how far I go, I just want to push myself and grow.”
Her proud mother, Carnie Wilson, reassured her, “Bottom line, you were born to sing.
When and Where to Watch ‘American Idol’ 2025?
American Idol airs Sundays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and streams the next day on Hulu.
